When launching a local newsletter, it's tempting to focus solely on content while treating visual branding as an afterthought. After all, if your information is valuable, does it really matter what it looks like?
According to newsletter operators who've seen measurable results from design improvements, the answer is a resounding yes.
Phat Chiem from The 518 in Albany experienced this firsthand when his newsletter underwent a branding transformation. After launching with what he describes as "very generic" branding featuring a local landmark, Chiem collaborated with Mike from The Catskill Screw to develop something more distinctive.
"The minute that we switched from the old branding to the new branding with the Beaver mascot, we definitely saw a lift in terms of engagement," Chiem shares. Even more impressively, "our cost of acquisition went down" when they tested social media advertising with the new branding.
This transformation wasn't random. It stemmed from thoughtful consideration of Albany's identity as one of America's oldest incorporated cities, with a rich history as a state capital. Working with his wife (an artist and photographer who co-publishes the newsletter), Chiem developed a visual identity that embraces this heritage.
The result? A distinctive look featuring historical maps of Albany with the Hudson River, a beaver mascot (nodding to New York State's historical beaver trade), and typography that hearkens back to old New York style. Even the background color – a subtle beige with an archival feel – contributes to the brand experience.
"When you open it, it puts you into this kind of world of the newsletter that's separate from anything else," Chiem explains. This visual distinction immediately separates The 518 from the sea of white-background emails flooding subscribers' inboxes.
TJ Larkin, host of the podcast and a newsletter operator himself, emphasizes that professional branding serves as a quality signal to potential subscribers: "Having put this real effort into your brand, people just instinctively know this can't just be AI because AI just can't or wouldn't do this."
This perception of quality matters immensely when building a newsletter business. As Chiem puts it, thoughtful branding demonstrates "you're putting a lot of thought behind the brand. You're putting a lot of thought that goes into the newsletter and people respond to that."
Perhaps most importantly, consistency across platforms reinforces brand recognition. The 518 maintains visual consistency across social media channels, using the same fonts, colors, and their beaver mascot consistently. As Mike from The Catskill Screw advised Chiem: "Make it so that when people see one of your graphic elements or headlines, they immediately associate that with your brand."
The good news? Creating distinctive branding doesn't necessarily require a massive budget or professional design services. With tools like Canva, Midjourney, and other AI design assistants, newsletter operators can develop quality branding with reasonable effort.
"It doesn't take that much effort," Chiem notes. "Just spend a little bit on Canva, maybe play around with Midjourney, and you'll come out with something nice."
For newsletter operators looking to stand out in increasingly crowded markets, thoughtful branding isn't just about aesthetics – it's a business advantage that directly impacts subscriber growth and engagement.
How I Can Help You Succeed
Before we dive into this week's insights, I want to make sure you know about all the resources available to support your local newsletter journey:
🎙️ The Podcast - Deep-dive conversations with successful newsletter operators sharing their playbooks and lessons learned | Link
📧 This Weekly Newsletter - Quick, actionable tips delivered straight to your inbox every week | Link
🧠 1:1 Consulting - Personalized guidance tailored to your specific newsletter challenges Link
🚀 Launch Accelerator - A structured program to help you go from idea to profitable newsletter in record time | Link
Subscribe to our newsletter.
Discover all these resources and more at localnewsletterinsider.com
Yes
